top of page

Perspective Change

Oct 31
4 min read

Updated: Nov 1

Author Will Duncan pictured in black and white, walking with a book in his hand while he was volunteering in Uganda.
A photo of myself taken by a kid borrowing my phone while I was volunteering in Uganda

One of the cardinal rules of storytelling is to write about what you know. A reader can tell if an author has only a superficial knowledge of a subject: heavy reliance on tropes, stereotypes, and sparse description are some of the hallmarks.


This, however, conflicts with the essence of creativity. Tolkien never truly walked Middle Earth, and Harper Lee did not have to grow up as a boy to write the respected To Kill a Mockingbird. Yet, they managed to captivate readers and convince them that their characters and situations are real in their minds.



It is common, especially with Christian paintings, to portray the subject in settings more familiar to the viewer, i.e. showing architecture of Italy (where these were made) rather than Israel.


Some of the differences can be eliminated by good research, detailed observation, and respect for the subject. Other times, all it takes is a quality imagination and an ability to empathize. Take, for example, The Book Thief, which is told from the perspective of Death. In a stroke of genius, Marcus Zusak decided that the setting (WWII Germany) would best be told from that point of view. By framing the entire story in that way, death literally seeps into every page, similar to how it must’ve felt living in Germany at the time.


Other authors, like William Faulkner in As I Lay Dying, use a whole cast of perspectives to stitch together narratives, allowing each voice to bring its own history and biases into each part of the story. How else could we have had a child spend a chapter declaring, “My mother is a fish,” as a step along the way of processing her death?



Author Will Duncan pictured in China in 2013, standing along a short wall with another man with a pagoda in the background.
My trip to China back in 2013 really opened my eyes to the importance of challenging myself in how I travel

One of the reasons I try things that make me nervous and travel and consume so many stories is to allow me to write with more authority on a variety of subjects (besides that fact that it can often be fun and you can learn a lot about yourself as well in the process.) There is no way I would have written Specks of Dust without having gone to Uganda and gotten the spark of the idea there, as well as so many firsthand observations and secondhand stories.


Nevertheless, despite my best attempt to treat my subject with as much care as possible, I must admit that there are moments of discomfort in writing about an experience so different from my own. It is a challenging balancing act, to tell a fake story as truthfully as possible.


I remember, after having finished my first draft, asking another volunteer who went to Uganda with me to read it and give me her opinion. She worked at the same orphanage as I had, and we shared many of the same experiences volunteering there, so I valued her opinion on how faithful my descriptions, characters, and situations were.



Even on longer hiking trips, like in Peru and Iceland, it is beneficial to have a local guide who can give a native parspective


One of the first questions she asked was whether I had given the draft to any Ugandans to read. This caught me off guard, and I was forced to admit that no, I had not.


It got me thinking as to why I did not ever ask any of the Ugandans I know to read the book. I’m certain part of it was fear. I manufactured character growth that is honestly too rare in Uganda: a nuanced view of Christianity and a generous view toward sexuality. As much as I tried to highlight the strength and resilience of children in the slums of Kampala, I also focused a lot on the inefficiencies and serious issues with nonprofits in the country. I suspected that they would not appreciate the portrayal, and that, being so deeply immersed in their own culture, they would resist some of the sharper citiques and perhaps even feel betrayed by how candidly (or negatively, I can easily imagine, in their opinion) I represented the work of an orphanage that was actively working day and night to raise up an incredibly disenfranchised community.


During this reflection, it occurred to me that there was another, deeper reason that I did not ask a Ugandan to read my book: Ugandans were not my target audience. If it were, I would have written the book very differently. Although I consider many aspects of the book to be universal, I wrote the book specifically for an American audience.



Attending religious services and visiting temples different from one's own Is a great way to gain a greater perspective. These include a mosque in Bosnia and Herzegovina, the Vatican City's Mass Service, a Buddhist Temple in Cambodia, and even a Hindu service in the USA.


This is itself an odd thing: to write about one kind of person for another group of people. It’s been done plenty of times before to varying degrees of success: Rudyard Kipling’s Jungle Book and Harriet Beecher Stowe’s Uncle Tom’s Cabin are two popular but problematic examples. There were still things I did to slightly distance myself from the perspective being told – narrating the story from 3rd person omniscient was a conscious decision.


Nevertheless, I have to live with this discomfort, while at the same time, I must remember that the story I told is underrepresented and important to get out there. I imagine Kipling and Stowe may have felt similarly at the time; I can only hope I treated my subject with enough care and respect that it will age well with time.


As I move on to other stories and subjects, I hope to play around more with perspective. All it takes is a paired reading of Jane Eyre and Wide Sargasso Sea to see how perspective alone can heavily alter a tale and potentially add whole new layers of depth and meaning.



A large mural covers a wall in Palermo, featuring important local figures that were killed by the Mafia.
In Palermo, where the Mafia is still active, one has the opportunity to lean into the stereotypes by taking a Godfather tour, or support the anti-mafia movement by taking a NO MAFIA tour, which discusses the fight to free Sicily from its control and also alter the narrative of the city's reputation. Above is a mural of important cops, lawyers, and politicians who were killed by the Mafia, one of the few pieces of wall that does not get covered in graffiti.

Comments


bottom of page